← All text tools

Car insurance deductible break-even calculator

Finds how many claim-free years a higher car insurance deductible needs to pay off through the lower premium, and the break-even claim chance.

  • Free
  • No sign-up
  • Works on any device

About Car insurance deductible break-even calculator

A higher deductible cuts your premium, but you pay more when you claim. The break-even point is simple: divide the extra deductible by the premium you save each year. Moving from a 500 to a 1,000 deductible while the premium drops from 1,400 to 1,250 saves 150 a year against 500 of extra exposure, so it takes 3.33 claim-free years to pay off, which means 4 whole years. Seen the other way, the higher deductible wins as long as you claim less than 30% of years. The page also shows the total saved over the years you keep the policy.

How to use Car insurance deductible break-even calculator

  1. Enter your current deductible and the higher one you are considering.
  2. Type the yearly premium quoted for each deductible, from the same insurer.
  3. Read the break-even years and the break-even claim chance, and decide whether you could afford the larger deductible if you had to claim.

Why use this tool?

Also known as

Frequently asked questions

How long until a higher deductible saves money?

The extra deductible divided by the yearly premium saving. If that is 3.33 years, you come out ahead after four years without a claim.

What is the break-even claim chance?

It is the premium saving divided by the extra deductible, here 30%. If you expect to claim less often than that, the higher deductible is cheaper on average.

Should I worry about small claims?

With a high deductible small damage will not be covered anyway, so you would not claim. Make sure you have savings set aside for the full deductible.

Is Car insurance deductible break-even calculator free?

Yes. Car insurance deductible break-even calculator on Toolipedia is free to use, with no sign-up and no watermark.

Is it safe to use?

Yes. Everything is worked out in your browser, and nothing you enter is sent to our server.

Does it work on my phone?

Yes. It works in any modern browser on Android and iPhone, as well as on tablets and computers. There's nothing to install.

Do I need an account?

No. Just open the page and use the tool. There's no sign-up and no email needed.

Can I put Car insurance deductible break-even calculator on my own website?

Yes. Use the Embed on your site button under the tool to copy a short piece of code and paste it into your page. It is free, needs no account, and the tool keeps working inside your page.

Related tools